Top 7 Fish You Can Catch in Islamorada Year-Round

Known as the “Sportfishing Capital of the World,” Islamorada offers anglers the thrill of fishing all year long. Whether you’re an experienced fisherman or a curious beginner, these seven species are waiting for you just off the coast—every month of the year.

1. Snapper

From yellowtail to mangrove snapper, these tasty fish are abundant and fun to catch on light tackle. Great for both beginners and seasoned anglers.

2. Grouper

Although some species have seasonal closures, species like black and red grouper can still be found year-round in deeper waters and reef edges.

3. Barracuda

Fast, aggressive, and exciting to catch—barracuda are available year-round and often found near wrecks and shallow reefs.

4. Amberjack

Strong and stubborn fighters, amberjack (aka “reef donkeys”) are found around deep wrecks and make for a serious challenge.

5. Shark

Nurse, bull, and blacktip sharks are commonly caught year-round in Islamorada. Catch-and-release is common, offering an exciting battle with nature.

6. Jack Crevalle

These tough fish put up an impressive fight and are readily available inshore and near reefs no matter the season.

7. Bonito

Often overlooked but incredibly strong fighters, bonito are a fun catch and a great target for light tackle or fly fishing.

Ready to Fish?
Whether you’re casting from a boat or joining a local charter, Islamorada’s rich waters guarantee action year-round. Pack your gear, and let the adventure begin!

“Hands Down, One of the best fishing Experience I’ve ever had! Captain Brooks is the best ” satisfied client

 

Why Islamorada Is the Sport-Fishing Capital of the World

Tucked between the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico, Islamorada in the Florida Keys proudly holds the title of the Sport-Fishing Capital of the World—and for good reason.

Unmatched Location

Islamorada offers easy access to both deep sea and backcountry fishing. Within minutes, anglers can target offshore giants like sailfish and tuna, or head to the calmer backwaters for tarpon, snook, and redfish.

Year-Round Fishing

No matter the season, Islamorada delivers. Thanks to its subtropical climate, there’s always something biting—snapper, grouper, mahi-mahi, bonefish, and even shark.

World-Class Charters and Guides

Home to some of the most experienced captains in the world, Islamorada boasts a fleet of fishing charters equipped for every skill level. These pros know the local waters like the back of their hand.

Record-Breaking History

Islamorada has seen more saltwater fishing records than almost anywhere else in the world. It’s a legendary destination for anglers chasing trophy catches and unforgettable experiences.

Fishing Community and Culture

This isn’t just a fishing spot—it’s a lifestyle. From local tackle shops to annual tournaments, the fishing culture runs deep in Islamorada, drawing anglers from all corners of the globe.

Cast Away in Paradise
Whether you’re a seasoned angler or new to the sport, Islamorada offers the perfect mix of adventure, challenge, and beauty that keeps fishermen coming back year after year.

“Hands Down, One of the best fishing Experience I’ve ever had! Captain Brooks is the best ” satisfied client

 

Beginner’s Guide to Deep Sea Fishing in the Florida Keys

The Florida Keys is a dream destination for anglers, and if you’re new to deep sea fishing, there’s no better place to cast your line. With its warm waters, abundant marine life, and expert charters, the Keys offer the perfect introduction to offshore fishing.

What to Expect
Deep sea fishing takes you miles offshore into the Atlantic, where you can reel in impressive catches like mahi-mahi, tuna, sailfish, and even marlin. Trips typically last half-day to full-day and are led by experienced captains who provide all the gear and guidance you need.

Best Time to Go
While fishing is great year-round, peak seasons vary by species. Spring and summer are ideal for mahi-mahi and tuna, while winter attracts sailfish. Always check the forecast and go with a licensed charter that knows local regulations and hot spots.

Tips for First-Timers

  • Dress comfortably with sun protection (hat, sunglasses, sunscreen)
  • Bring snacks, water, and motion sickness remedies just in case
  • Listen to your captain—they know the waters best!

Whether you’re chasing trophy fish or just want an exciting day at sea, deep sea fishing in the Florida Keys offers unforgettable experiences for beginners. It’s not just about the catch—it’s about the thrill of the ocean, the views, and the stories you’ll take home.

“Hands Down, One of the best fishing Experience I’ve ever had! Captain Brooks is the best ” satisfied client

 

Reef vs. Offshore Fishing: What’s Best for Your Next Charter?

Planning a fishing trip in the Florida Keys? One of the first decisions you’ll face is choosing between reef and offshore fishing. Both offer incredible experiences—but the best option for you depends on what kind of adventure you’re after.

Reef Fishing: Action-Packed & Family-Friendly

Reef fishing takes place in shallower waters near coral reefs and wrecks. It’s ideal for beginners, families, or anyone who wants steady action without going too far offshore.

Common catches: Yellowtail snapper, grouper, hogfish, barracuda
Best for: Shorter trips, calmer waters, and lots of bites
Pro tip: Great if you want to catch and cook your own dinner!

Offshore Fishing: Big Game, Big Thrills

Offshore (or deep sea) fishing takes you miles out into open ocean, where the big game lives. These trips are all about chasing trophy fish and testing your skills.

Common catches: Mahi-mahi, tuna, sailfish, marlin
Best for: Experienced anglers, adventure-seekers, and longer trips
Pro tip: Bring motion sickness meds just in case—it gets choppy out there!

So, What’s Right for You?
If you’re looking for a relaxed day with lots of bites and family fun, reef fishing is the way to go. But if you’re ready for a thrilling chase and dream of landing a monster catch, offshore fishing is your ultimate adventure.

No matter what you choose, the Florida Keys promise an unforgettable fishing experience.

“Hands Down, One of the best fishing Experience I’ve ever had! Captain Brooks is the best ” satisfied client

 

What to Pack for Your Fishing Trip with Captain Brooks

Getting ready for an exciting day on the water with Captain Brooks? Whether it’s your first charter or you’re a seasoned angler, packing the right gear makes all the difference. Here’s a quick checklist to ensure you’re fully prepared for your fishing adventure.

Essentials to Bring

  • Valid Fishing License (if required – check with the captain beforehand)
  • Photo ID
  • Cash for tips (customary for your hardworking crew!)

Sun & Weather Protection

  • Polarized sunglasses
  • Sunscreen (reef-safe preferred)
  • Lightweight hat or cap
  • Long-sleeve UV-protective shirt

Food & Drinks

  • Plenty of water
  • Snacks or a packed lunch (especially for full-day charters)
  • Cooler for your catch (ask Captain Brooks if ice is provided)

Comfortable Clothing

  • Quick-dry clothing
  • Non-slip shoes or boat sandals
  • Light rain jacket (weather can change quickly!)

Optional Items

  • Camera or GoPro for capturing big catches
  • Motion sickness medication (just in case!)
  • Personal fishing gear (if you prefer your own, though Captain Brooks provides quality tackle)

Bonus Tip: Leave valuables at home—saltwater and electronics don’t mix well. Just bring the essentials and a good attitude, and Captain Brooks will handle the rest!

Get ready for a day full of fun, fish, and Florida sunshine. Tight lines!

“Hands Down, One of the best fishing Experience I’ve ever had! Captain Brooks is the best ” satisfied client